Having backwards compatibility for !include and 'constraint:' is silly
without also having backwards compatibility for 'category:', because
that forces a binding change anyway.
Add backwards compatibility for 'category:', and just print a
deprecation warning when it's used.
Also move tests for deprecated features into a dedicated
test-bindings/deprecated.yaml binding, instead of piggybacking on other
tests.
Signed-off-by: Ulf Magnusson <Ulf.Magnusson@nordicsemi.no>
Have
include: foo.dts
include: [foo.dts, bar.dts]
instead of
inherits:
!include foo.dts
inherits:
!include [foo.dts, bar.dts]
This is a nicer and shorter and less cryptic syntax, and will make it
possible to get rid of the custom PyYAML constructor for '!include'
later.
'inherits: !include ...' is still supported for backwards compatibility
for now. Later on, I'm planning to mass-replace it, add a deprecation
warning if it's used, and document 'include:'. Then the '!include'
implementation can be removed a bit later.
'!include' has caused issues in the past (see the comment above the
add_constructor() call), gets iffy with multiple EDT instances, and
makes the code harder to follow.
I'm guessing '!include' might've been intended to be useful outside of
'inherits:' originally, but that's the only place where it's used. It's
undocumented that it's possible to put it elsewhere.
To implement the backwards compatibility, the code just transforms
inherits:
!include foo.dts
into
inherits:
- foo.dts
and treats 'inherits:' similarly to 'include:'. Previously, !include
inserted the contents of the included file instead.
Some more sanity checks for 'include:'/'inherits:' are included as well.
Signed-off-by: Ulf Magnusson <Ulf.Magnusson@nordicsemi.no>
The 'category: required/optional' setting for properties is just a
yes/no thing. Using a boolean makes it clearer, so have
'required: true/false' instead.
Print a clear error when 'category:' is used:
edtlib.EDTError: please put 'required: true' instead of 'category:
required' in 'properties: foo: ...' in
test-bindings/sub-node-parent.yaml - 'category' has been removed
The old scripts in scripts/dts/ ignore this setting, and only print a
warning if 'category: required' in an inherited binding is changed to
'category: optional'. Remove that code, since the new scripts already
have the same check.
The replacement was done with
git ls-files 'dts/bindings/*.yaml' | xargs sed -i \
-e 's/category:\s*required/required: true/' \
-e 's/category:\s*optional/required: false/'
dts/binding-template.yaml is updated as well.
Signed-off-by: Ulf Magnusson <Ulf.Magnusson@nordicsemi.no>
Sanity-checking each !included file separately was inherited from the
old scripts. It makes it messy to check that combinations of fields make
sense, e.g. to check 'const:' or 'default:' against 'type:', since those
fields might come from different files (this is handy, since it makes
sense to just add/change a 'const:' value, for example).
Drop the requirement that each !included file is a complete binding in
itself, and treat them as binding fragments instead. Only check the
final merged binding.
This also means that !included files no longer need to have a
'description:' or 'title:' (those have always been unused for !included
files), so remove those, and add comments that explain what the
fragments are for instead. That should demystify bindings a bit.
Also fix the descriptions of i2c.yaml, i2s.yaml, spi.yaml, and
uart.yaml. They're for controllers, not devices. These are copy-paste
error from the corresponding device .yaml files.
Piggyback some indentation consistency nits in binding-template.yaml.
Signed-off-by: Ulf Magnusson <Ulf.Magnusson@nordicsemi.no>
Add a new DTS/binding parser to scripts/dts/ for generating
generated_dts_board.conf and generated_dts_board_unfixed.h.
The old code is kept to generate some deprecated defines, using the
--deprecated-only flag. It will be removed later.
The new parser is implemented in three files in scripts/dts/:
dtlib.py:
A low-level .dts parsing library. This is similar to devicetree.py in
the old code, but is a general robust DTS parser that doesn't rely on
preprocessing.
edtlib.py (e for extended):
A library built on top of dtlib.py that brings together data from DTS
files and bindings and creates Device instances with all the data for
a device.
gen_defines.py:
A script that uses edtlib.py to generate generated_dts_board.conf and
generated_dts_board_unfixed.h. Corresponds to extract_dts_includes.py
and the files in extract/ in the old code.
testdtlib.py:
Test suite for dtlib.py. Can be run directly as a script.
testedtlib.py (uses test.dts and test-bindings/):
Test suite for edtlib.py. Can be run directly as a script.
The test suites will be run automatically in CI.
The new code turns some things that were warnings (or not checked) in
the old code into errors, like missing properties that are specified
with 'category: required' in the binding for the node.
The code includes lots of documentation and tries to give helpful error
messages instead of Python errors.
Co-authored-by: Kumar Gala <kumar.gala@linaro.org>
Signed-off-by: Ulf Magnusson <Ulf.Magnusson@nordicsemi.no>
Ulf Magnusson